How did Gollum bite off Frodo's finger? | Page 2 | The Tolkien Forum
WEB197. May 1, 2002. #24. ...and all the while far below there was a rumour and a trouble as of great engines throbbing and labouring. Well the volcano was active but it wasn't actually a bursting volcano. Sound could be heard since the only sound coming from the volcano was a deep roumor and Frodo was shouting to Sam.
What did Gandalf mean by Gollum's fate might have happened to …
WEBSep 30, 2019 — Search titles only By: Search Advanced search…
What else did he want them for? | The Tolkien Forum
WEBJul 22, 2003 — Is it only I, or does anyone else suspect that the Enemy may have wanted a Hobbit for some other purpose than mere acquisition of the Ring, or information concerning it? I suspect that he may have wanted them for some other evil sport, perhaps to make a new creature in mockery of Hobbits. I...
Any news on the movie, The Hobbit? | The Tolkien Forum
WEBSep 14, 2006 — ANY NEWS ON THE Movie The Hobbet Hi was Hopeing some on in here could tell me if they know of any new about them Movie they might make of the Hobbet and...
Hobbit Reviews ~ With Spoilers | The Tolkien Forum
WEBDec 17, 2012 — Sorry Bucky, had to start this one because you can't really discuss the films without revealing some elements
what if Hobbit and lord of the rings were the only works of …
WEBDec 9, 2021 — Search titles only By: Search Advanced search…
who do you think is the true hero of lotr? | Page 37 | The Tolkien ...
WEBAug 23, 2022 — Search titles only By: Search Advanced search…
Peter Jackson Hints at the Hobbit | Page 4 | The Tolkien Forum
WEBDec 2, 2003 — Unfortunately Ian Holm is too old to play Bilbo in his thirties (was he thirty when he started the journey..?). They would have to find a younger actor. Some who is totally unknown. Ian Holm could be in the movie as one telling stories of his previous adventures. Gandalf can not be changed...
LOTR Would Have Been Better Without The evil sam! Obviously!
WEBMar 11, 2003 — What is up, dudes? Having all kinds of fun? Oh, I hope so! Why not? Anyways, I was talking about this in some little debating bar we have in the...
who do you think is the true hero of lotr?
WEBOct 14, 2002 — Frodo couldn’t cast the ring into the fire and chose to keep it. Gollum turned out to be the reason it was destroyed so isn’t Gollum in a round about way the real hero of LOTR? I always assumed Eru was the hero. Tolkien, in letter 192, basically says that He took over once Frodo got to Mt...